| Commonwealth Coast Conference | CCC | Endicott College | Gulls | Beverly | Massachusetts |
| Commonwealth Coast Conference | CCC | Nichols College | Bison | Dudley | Massachusetts |
| Commonwealth Coast Conference | CCC | Salve Regina University | Seahawks | Newport | Rhode Island |
| Commonwealth Coast Conference | CCC | Suffolk University | Rams | Boston | Massachusetts |
| Commonwealth Coast Conference | CCC | University of New England | Nor'easters | Biddeford | Maine |
| Commonwealth Coast Conference | CCC | Wentworth Institute of Technology | Leopards | Boston | Massachusetts |
| Commonwealth Coast Conference | CCC | Western New England University | Golden Bears | Springfield | Massachusetts |
| Massachusetts State College Athletic Association | MASCAC | Fitchburg State University | Falcons | Fitchburg | Massachusetts |
| Massachusetts State College Athletic Association | MASCAC | Framingham State University | Rams | Framingham | Massachusetts |
| Massachusetts State College Athletic Association | MASCAC | University of Massachusetts Dartmouth | Corsairs | Dartmouth | Massachusetts |
| Massachusetts State College Athletic Association | MASCAC | Westfield State University | Owls | Westfield | Massachusetts |
| Massachusetts State College Athletic Association | MASCAC | Worcester State University | Lancers | Worcester | Massachusetts |
| Massachusetts State College Athletic Association | MASCAC | Massachusetts College of Liberal Arts (Joining 2023-24) | Trailblazers | North Adams | Massachusetts |
| Massachusetts State College Athletic Association | MASCAC | Salem State University | Vikings | Salem | Massachusetts |
| Massachusetts State College Athletic Association | MASCAC | Plymouth State University | Panthers | Plymouth | New Hampshire |
| Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | MIAC | Augsburg University | Auggies | Minneapolis | Minnesota |
| Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | MIAC | Bethel University | Royals | Arden Hills | Minnesota |
| Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | MIAC | Concordia College (Minnesota) | Cobbers | Moorhead | Minnesota |
| Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | MIAC | Gustavus Adolphus College | Golden Gusties | St. Peter | Minnesota |
| Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | MIAC | Hamline University | Pipers | Saint Paul | Minnesota |
| Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | MIAC | Saint John's University | Johnnies | Collegeville | Minnesota |
| Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | MIAC | St. Mary’s University | Cardinals | Winona | Minnesota |
| Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | MIAC | St. Olaf College | Oles | Northfield | Minnesota |
| Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | MIAC | College of St. Scholastica | Saints | Duluth | Minnesota |
| Northern Collegiate Hockey Association | NCHA | Adrian College | Bulldogs | Adrian | Michigan |
| Northern Collegiate Hockey Association | NCHA | Aurora University | Spartans | Aurora | Illinois |
| Northern Collegiate Hockey Association | NCHA | Concordia University (Wisconsin) | Falcons | Mequon | Wisconsin |
| Northern Collegiate Hockey Association | NCHA | Finlandia University | Lions | Hancock | Michigan |
| Northern Collegiate Hockey Association | NCHA | Lake Forest College | Foresters | Lake Forest | Illinois |
| Northern Collegiate Hockey Association | NCHA | Lawrence University | Vikings | Appleton | Wisconsin |
| Northern Collegiate Hockey Association | NCHA | Marian University | Sabres | Fond du Lac | Wisconsin |
| Northern Collegiate Hockey Association | NCHA | Milwaukee School of Engineering | Raiders | Milwaukee | Wisconsin |
| Northern Collegiate Hockey Association | NCHA | St. Norbert College | Green Knights | De Pere | Wisconsin |
| Northern Collegiate Hockey Association | NCHA | Trine University | Thunder | Angola | Indiana |
| New England Hockey Conference | NEHC | Babson College | Beavers | Wellesley | Massachusetts |
| New England Hockey Conference | NEHC | Castleton University | Spartans | Castleton | Vermont |
| New England Hockey Conference | NEHC | Elmira College | Soaring Eagles | Elmira | New York |
| New England Hockey Conference | NEHC | Hobart College | Statesmen | Geneva | New York |
| New England Hockey Conference | NEHC | Johnson and Wales University | Wildcats | Providence | Rhode Island |
| New England Hockey Conference | NEHC | University of Massachusetts Boston | Beacons | Dorchester | Massachusetts |
| New England Hockey Conference | NEHC | New England College | Pilgrims | Henniker | New Hampshire |
| New England Hockey Conference | NEHC | Norwich University | Cadets | Northfield | Vermont |
| New England Hockey Conference | NEHC | Skidmore College | Thoroughbreds | Saratoga Springs | New York |
| New England Hockey Conference | NEHC | University of Southern Maine | Huskies | Portland | Maine |
| New England Small College Athletic Conference | NESCAC | Amherst College | Mammoths | Amherst | Massachusetts |
| New England Small College Athletic Conference | NESCAC | Bowdoin College | Polar Bears | Brunswick | Maine |
| New England Small College Athletic Conference | NESCAC | Colby College | Mules | Waterville | Maine |
| New England Small College Athletic Conference | NESCAC | Connecticut College | Camels | New London | Connecticut |
| New England Small College Athletic Conference | NESCAC | Hamilton College | Continentals | Clinton | New York |
| New England Small College Athletic Conference | NESCAC | Middlebury College | Panthers | Middlebury | Vermont |
| New England Small College Athletic Conference | NESCAC | Trinity College | Bantams | Hartford | Connecticut |
| New England Small College Athletic Conference | NESCAC | Tufts University | Jumbos | Medford | Massachusetts |
| New England Small College Athletic Conference | NESCAC | Wesleyan University | Cardinals | Middletown | Connecticut |
| New England Small College Athletic Conference | NESCAC | Williams College | Ephs | Williamstown | Massachusetts |
| State University of New York Athletic Conference | SUNYAC | SUNY-Brockport | Golden Eagles | Brockport | New York |
| State University of New York Athletic Conference | SUNYAC | SUNY-Cortland | Red Dragons | Cortland | New York |
| State University of New York Athletic Conference | SUNYAC | SUNY-Fredonia | Blue Devils | Fredonia | New York |
| State University of New York Athletic Conference | SUNYAC | SUNY-Geneseo | Knights | Geneseo | New York |
| State University of New York Athletic Conference | SUNYAC | SUNY-Oswego | Lakers | Oswego | New York |
| State University of New York Athletic Conference | SUNYAC | SUNY-Plattsburgh | Cardinals | Plattsburgh | New York |
| State University of New York Athletic Conference | SUNYAC | SUNY-Potsdam | Bears | Potsdam | New York |
| State University of New York Athletic Conference | SUNYAC | Buffalo State College | Bengals | Buffalo | New York |
| State University of New York Athletic Conference | SUNYAC | SUNY-Morrisville | Mustangs | Morrisville | New York |
| United Collegiate Hockey Conference | UCHC | Alvernia University | Golden Wolves | Reading | Pennsylvania |
| United Collegiate Hockey Conference | UCHC | Arcadia University | Knights | Glenside | Pennsylvania |
| United Collegiate Hockey Conference | UCHC | Chatham University | Cougars | Pittsburgh | Pennsylvania |
| United Collegiate Hockey Conference | UCHC | King's College | Monarchs | Wilkes-Barre | Pennsylvania |
| United Collegiate Hockey Conference | UCHC | Lebanon Valley College | Flying Dutchmen | Annville | Pennsylvania |
| United Collegiate Hockey Conference | UCHC | Manhattanville College | Valiants | Purchase | New York |
| United Collegiate Hockey Conference | UCHC | Nazareth College | Golden Flyers | Rochester | New York |
| United Collegiate Hockey Conference | UCHC | Neumann University | Knights | Aston | Pennsylvania |
| United Collegiate Hockey Conference | UCHC | Stevenson University | Mustangs | Stevenson | Maryland |
| United Collegiate Hockey Conference | UCHC | Utica University | Pioneers | Utica | New York |
| United Collegiate Hockey Conference | UCHC | Wilkes University | Colonels | Wilkes-Barre | Pennsylvania |
| Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | WIAC | Northland College | Lumberjacks | Ashland | Wisconsin |
| Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | WIAC | University of Wisconsin–Eau Claire | Blugolds | Eau Claire | Wisconsin |
| Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | WIAC | University of Wisconsin–River Falls | Falcons | River Falls | Wisconsin |
| Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | WIAC | University of Wisconsin–Stevens Point | Pointers | Stevens Point | Wisconsin |
| Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | WIAC | University of Wisconsin–Stout | Blue Devils | Menomonie | Wisconsin |
| Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | WIAC | University of Wisconsin–Superior | Yellowjackets | Superior | Wisconsin |
| Independent | | Albertus Magnus College | Falcons | New Haven | Connecticut |
| Independent | | Anna Maria College | Amcats | Paxton | Massachusetts |
| Independent | | Rivier University | Raiders | Nashua | New Hampshire |
| Independent | | SUNY-Canton | Kangaroos | Canton | New York |
| Northeast-10 (Division II) | NE-10 | Assumption University | Greyhounds | Worcester | Massachusetts |
| Northeast-10 (Division II) | NE-10 | Franklin Pierce University | Ravens | Rindge | New Hampshire |
| Northeast-10 (Division II) | NE-10 | Post University | Eagles | Waterbury | Connecticut |
| Northeast-10 (Division II) | NE-10 | Saint Anselm College | Hawks | Goffstown | New Hampshire |
| Northeast-10 (Division II) | NE-10 | Saint Michael's College | Purple Knights | Colchester | Vermont |
| Northeast-10 (Division II) | NE-10 | Southern New Hampshire University | Penmen | Manchester | New Hampshire |
