| Commonwealth Coast Conference | CCC | Endicott College | Gulls | Beverly | Massachusetts |
| Commonwealth Coast Conference | CCC | Nichols College | Bison | Dudley | Massachusetts |
| Commonwealth Coast Conference | CCC | Salve Regina University | Seahawks | Newport | Rhode Island |
| Commonwealth Coast Conference | CCC | Suffolk University | Rams | Boston | Massachusetts |
| Commonwealth Coast Conference | CCC | University of New England | Nor'easters | Biddeford | Maine |
| Commonwealth Coast Conference | CCC | Wentworth Institute of Technology | Leopards | Boston | Massachusetts |
| Commonwealth Coast Conference | CCC | Western New England University | Golden Bears | Springfield | Massachusetts |
| Massachusetts State College Athletic Association | MASCAC | Fitchburg State University | Falcons | Fitchburg | Massachusetts |
| Massachusetts State College Athletic Association | MASCAC | Framingham State University | Rams | Framingham | Massachusetts |
| Massachusetts State College Athletic Association | MASCAC | University of Massachusetts Dartmouth | Corsairs | Dartmouth | Massachusetts |
| Massachusetts State College Athletic Association | MASCAC | Westfield State University | Owls | Westfield | Massachusetts |
| Massachusetts State College Athletic Association | MASCAC | Worcester State University | Lancers | Worcester | Massachusetts |
| Massachusetts State College Athletic Association | MASCAC | Massachusetts College of Liberal Arts (Joining 2023-24) | Trailblazers | North Adams | Massachusetts |
| Massachusetts State College Athletic Association | MASCAC | Salem State University | Vikings | Salem | Massachusetts |
| Massachusetts State College Athletic Association | MASCAC | Plymouth State University | Panthers | Plymouth | New Hampshire |
| Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | MIAC | Augsburg University | Auggies | Minneapolis | Minnesota |
| Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | MIAC | Bethel University | Royals | Arden Hills | Minnesota |
| Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | MIAC | Concordia College (Minnesota) | Cobbers | Moorhead | Minnesota |
| Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | MIAC | Gustavus Adolphus College | Golden Gusties | St. Peter | Minnesota |
| Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | MIAC | Hamline University | Pipers | Saint Paul | Minnesota |
| Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | MIAC | Saint John's University | Johnnies | Collegeville | Minnesota |
| Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | MIAC | St. Mary’s University | Cardinals | Winona | Minnesota |
| Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | MIAC | St. Olaf College | Oles | Northfield | Minnesota |
| Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | MIAC | College of St. Scholastica | Saints | Duluth | Minnesota |
| Northern Collegiate Hockey Association | NCHA | Adrian College | Bulldogs | Adrian | Michigan |
| Northern Collegiate Hockey Association | NCHA | Aurora University | Spartans | Aurora | Illinois |
| Northern Collegiate Hockey Association | NCHA | Concordia University (Wisconsin) | Falcons | Mequon | Wisconsin |
| Northern Collegiate Hockey Association | NCHA | Finlandia University | Lions | Hancock | Michigan |
| Northern Collegiate Hockey Association | NCHA | Lake Forest College | Foresters | Lake Forest | Illinois |
| Northern Collegiate Hockey Association | NCHA | Lawrence University | Vikings | Appleton | Wisconsin |
| Northern Collegiate Hockey Association | NCHA | Marian University | Sabres | Fond du Lac | Wisconsin |
| Northern Collegiate Hockey Association | NCHA | Milwaukee School of Engineering | Raiders | Milwaukee | Wisconsin |
| Northern Collegiate Hockey Association | NCHA | St. Norbert College | Green Knights | De Pere | Wisconsin |
| Northern Collegiate Hockey Association | NCHA | Trine University | Thunder | Angola | Indiana |
| New England Hockey Conference | NEHC | Babson College | Beavers | Wellesley | Massachusetts |
| New England Hockey Conference | NEHC | Castleton University | Spartans | Castleton | Vermont |
| New England Hockey Conference | NEHC | Elmira College | Soaring Eagles | Elmira | New York |
| New England Hockey Conference | NEHC | Hobart College | Statesmen | Geneva | New York |
| New England Hockey Conference | NEHC | Johnson and Wales University | Wildcats | Providence | Rhode Island |
| New England Hockey Conference | NEHC | University of Massachusetts Boston | Beacons | Dorchester | Massachusetts |
| New England Hockey Conference | NEHC | New England College | Pilgrims | Henniker | New Hampshire |
| New England Hockey Conference | NEHC | Norwich University | Cadets | Northfield | Vermont |
| New England Hockey Conference | NEHC | Skidmore College | Thoroughbreds | Saratoga Springs | New York |
| New England Hockey Conference | NEHC | University of Southern Maine | Huskies | Portland | Maine |
| New England Small College Athletic Conference | NESCAC | Amherst College | Mammoths | Amherst | Massachusetts |
| New England Small College Athletic Conference | NESCAC | Bowdoin College | Polar Bears | Brunswick | Maine |
| New England Small College Athletic Conference | NESCAC | Colby College | Mules | Waterville | Maine |
| New England Small College Athletic Conference | NESCAC | Connecticut College | Camels | New London | Connecticut |
| New England Small College Athletic Conference | NESCAC | Hamilton College | Continentals | Clinton | New York |
| New England Small College Athletic Conference | NESCAC | Middlebury College | Panthers | Middlebury | Vermont |
| New England Small College Athletic Conference | NESCAC | Trinity College | Bantams | Hartford | Connecticut |
| New England Small College Athletic Conference | NESCAC | Tufts University | Jumbos | Medford | Massachusetts |
| New England Small College Athletic Conference | NESCAC | Wesleyan University | Cardinals | Middletown | Connecticut |
| New England Small College Athletic Conference | NESCAC | Williams College | Ephs | Williamstown | Massachusetts |
| State University of New York Athletic Conference | SUNYAC | SUNY-Brockport | Golden Eagles | Brockport | New York |
| State University of New York Athletic Conference | SUNYAC | SUNY-Cortland | Red Dragons | Cortland | New York |
| State University of New York Athletic Conference | SUNYAC | SUNY-Fredonia | Blue Devils | Fredonia | New York |
| State University of New York Athletic Conference | SUNYAC | SUNY-Geneseo | Knights | Geneseo | New York |
| State University of New York Athletic Conference | SUNYAC | SUNY-Oswego | Lakers | Oswego | New York |
| State University of New York Athletic Conference | SUNYAC | SUNY-Plattsburgh | Cardinals | Plattsburgh | New York |
| State University of New York Athletic Conference | SUNYAC | SUNY-Potsdam | Bears | Potsdam | New York |
| State University of New York Athletic Conference | SUNYAC | Buffalo State College | Bengals | Buffalo | New York |
| State University of New York Athletic Conference | SUNYAC | SUNY-Morrisville | Mustangs | Morrisville | New York |
| United Collegiate Hockey Conference | UCHC | Alvernia University | Golden Wolves | Reading | Pennsylvania |
| United Collegiate Hockey Conference | UCHC | Arcadia University | Knights | Glenside | Pennsylvania |
| United Collegiate Hockey Conference | UCHC | Chatham University | Cougars | Pittsburgh | Pennsylvania |
| United Collegiate Hockey Conference | UCHC | King's College | Monarchs | Wilkes-Barre | Pennsylvania |
| United Collegiate Hockey Conference | UCHC | Lebanon Valley College | Flying Dutchmen | Annville | Pennsylvania |
| United Collegiate Hockey Conference | UCHC | Manhattanville College | Valiants | Purchase | New York |
| United Collegiate Hockey Conference | UCHC | Nazareth College | Golden Flyers | Rochester | New York |
| United Collegiate Hockey Conference | UCHC | Neumann University | Knights | Aston | Pennsylvania |
| United Collegiate Hockey Conference | UCHC | Stevenson University | Mustangs | Stevenson | Maryland |
| United Collegiate Hockey Conference | UCHC | Utica University | Pioneers | Utica | New York |
| United Collegiate Hockey Conference | UCHC | Wilkes University | Colonels | Wilkes-Barre | Pennsylvania |
| Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | WIAC | Northland College | Lumberjacks | Ashland | Wisconsin |
| Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | WIAC | University of Wisconsin–Eau Claire | Blugolds | Eau Claire | Wisconsin |
| Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | WIAC | University of Wisconsin–River Falls | Falcons | River Falls | Wisconsin |
| Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | WIAC | University of Wisconsin–Stevens Point | Pointers | Stevens Point | Wisconsin |
| Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | WIAC | University of Wisconsin–Stout | Blue Devils | Menomonie | Wisconsin |
| Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | WIAC | University of Wisconsin–Superior | Yellowjackets | Superior | Wisconsin |
| Independent | | Albertus Magnus College | Falcons | New Haven | Connecticut |
| Independent | | Anna Maria College | Amcats | Paxton | Massachusetts |
| Independent | | Rivier University | Raiders | Nashua | New Hampshire |
| Independent | | SUNY-Canton | Kangaroos | Canton | New York |
| Northeast-10 (Division II) | NE-10 | Assumption University | Greyhounds | Worcester | Massachusetts |
| Northeast-10 (Division II) | NE-10 | Franklin Pierce University | Ravens | Rindge | New Hampshire |
| Northeast-10 (Division II) | NE-10 | Post University | Eagles | Waterbury | Connecticut |
| Northeast-10 (Division II) | NE-10 | Saint Anselm College | Hawks | Goffstown | New Hampshire |
| Northeast-10 (Division II) | NE-10 | Saint Michael's College | Purple Knights | Colchester | Vermont |
| Northeast-10 (Division II) | NE-10 | Southern New Hampshire University | Penmen | Manchester | New Hampshire |
College Universel Gatineau
College Universel Sherbrooke
Hawkesbury Knights
Kingston Wranglers
Somang LL Hockey
Montreal Black Vees
Atlanta Mad Hatters
Bold City Battalion
Florida Eels
Florida Junior Blades
Palm Beach Typhoon
Tampa Bay Juniors
Battle Creek Kernels
Cincinnati Cyclones
Columbus Mavericks
Fresh Coast Freeze
Metro Jets
Nashville Spartans
Toledo Cherokee
Brooklyn Aviators
Connecticut Junior Rangers
Elmira Impact
Hershey Cubs
Jersey Hitmen
Mercer Chiefs
P.A.L. Junior Islanders
Red Bank Generals
Rockets Hockey Club
West Chester Wolves
Wilkes-Barre Scranton Knights
Chicago Cougars
Chicago Crush
Decatur Blaze
Fort Wayne Spacemen
MJDP
Motor City Gamblers
Dells Ducks
Hudson Havoc
Isanti Outlaws
Minnesota Blue Ox
Minnesota Moose
Minnesota Mullets
Minnesota Squatch
Steele County Blades
Wisconsin Rapids Riverkings
Boston Junior Bruins
College Universel Gatineau
Islanders Hockey Club
Northern Cyclones
South Shore Kings
Springfield Pics
Twin City Thunder
Utica Jr Comets
Bellingham Blazers
Bremerton Sockeyes
Colorado Fighting Elk
Rogue Valley Royals
Seattle Totems
Vernal Oilers
Bakersfield Roughnecks
Fresno Monsters
Henderson Force
Lake Tahoe Lakers
Long Beach Bombers
Ontario Jr Reign
San Diego Sabers
Ventura Vikings
Carolina Jr Hurricanes
Charlotte Rush
Columbia Infantry
Hampton Roads Whalers
Potomac Patriots
